Kothari, RitaRitaKothari2025-09-042025-09-042014-05-010012-9976https://d8.irins.org/handle/IITG2025/29614I am writing with respect to the review of my book Memories and Movements: Borders and Communities in Banni, Kutch, Gujarat by Aparna Kapadia inEPW (“Sindhiness beyond Sindh”, 26 April 2014). Kapadia suggests a “lack of engagement and acknowledgment of previous scholarship that is about the same region and explores nearly identical issues”.en-USBook reviewBook reviewMemories and MovementsNorthern kutchScholarshipson GujaratArticlepp. 5Article123456789/512